Wednesday, 22 April 2009

Pirates made to walk the plank

The Pirate Bay story broke at the end of last week, as I was transporting myself back from my home in France to the UK. This week has been somewhat manic at school, as we get ready to bid farewell to our A level Media students, so forgive the tardiness of this post.

In essence, in case you missed it, the Pirate Bay trial saw one of the largest peer-to-peer file sharing services taken to court and its four founders successfully prosecuted for copyright theft.

Their argument, that they weren't hosting the content, merely providing the infrastructure that allowed thousands of users to make file transfers, was rejected by the judge in Sweden. 

As well as large fines all four have been sentenced to a year in prison. An appeal has been launched.

The bottom line is that it's wrong to take work that someone has spent money and creative capital in producing and distribute it for free. It's morally dubious and legally banned.

I am one who thinks there does need to be a radical overhaul of the system - what about a DRM  program that allows users to send content for which they've paid the full price to a friend, who then has to pay a reduced fee for the hand-me-down content? In effect, this generates secondary and tertiary sales, while ensuring the point of sale price is paid for at least once. The increased use of embedded advertising might be another way to make content free to users, but still profitable for content producers. 

Whatever the future system of paying for creative content turns out to be, as I always say to my students, if you can't afford it then you can't have it. I remember having to save up to buy records and PC games as a kid. This generation seems to think they can have it all and screw the consequences. As many of them are planning to go into various branches of the creative media, I'll be interested to see what their views are once their content's been ripped and the cheques are failing to turn up in the post!


Don said...

Good points, especially the concept, "If you can't buy it, you can't have it." and "Wait til someone rips you off..." (paraphrased)

I'm planning on reading your last couple of posts this weekend. I read them once, which was not enough.

Always fun pondering your musings.


Sacha van Straten said...

Hi Don,

I think as educators we have an obligation to explain the ramifications of careless/thoughtless behaviour in the digital world to those we teach.

Certainly the message doesn't seem to be getting through and I think it may come down to people like us to do our best to spread responsible practice amongst the younger generations.

I'm glad you find my postings of some use - that's good to know. I'm almost up to a 100 posts, which will be a great milestone (or is that a blogstone?) to reach.

My last posting about free online tools from Google may be of use to you, as I think the audio indexing and timeline utilities offer lots of scope when working with kids who have learning difficulties.

All the best as always,